Why My Soul Is Held Hostage by the Prince of Hearts

Book: Finale by Stephanie Garber

Reviewed by Ashley M

Rating: 4/5

Overview
Dates read: April 16 – June 2, 2026
I was still thinking about this story weeks after finishing it. Stephanie Garber builds a world of illusions, but Finale is ultimately a high-stakes tale of love, danger, and obsession. If you enjoy dark, atmospheric fantasies filled with perilous bargains and emotional intensity, this book is for you.
What I Loved
The romance payoff. The emotional payoff is top-notch, highlighting the struggle between what the characters want and what they truly need. The chemistry is electric, built on sweeping, intimate moments and charming grins, and when the masks slip, the tension is completely believable.

A persistent dread. Don't let the swoon fool you. Ancient entities shatter the whimsical world into a cutthroat battlefield, and certain grand performances ring hollow: glittering smiles are just masks for a captive audience.

Living magic. My favorite part. The illicit markets become shimmering fairy bazaars where the price of admission is often your soul, and every transaction carries the terror that your prized relic will be your undoing. Garber turns a fairytale into a literal nightmare.

Fashion as armor. The chameleon-like magic, where a gown ripples from raging red leather into steel-plated armor, is the world-building at its most potent.

What Didn't Work
The chaotic timeline occasionally breaks the magic system's immersion, though the high stakes keep it captivating. Also, take the visceral elements seriously: terrifying creatures and brutal violence give even the grandest events a grotesque weight.
Verdict
4/5 stars: Great! A gripping climax that tests the true cost of power and independence, and how far one will go to reclaim their own destiny. Perfect for that "I-will-ruin-you-to-save-you" energy.
Read next:
The Cruel Prince by Holly Black

Belladonna by Adalyn Grace

Hotel Magnifique by Emily J. Taylor

Full review on Medium: https://medium.com/p/2c0312fd4852

Read full review on ARC Library