The Sword of Kaigen

Book: The Sword of Kaigen by M.L. Wang

Reviewed by plotdrunk

Rating: 4.25/5

I loved so much of this book, which only made the ending that much more frustrating. I think this author's pacing maybe just isn't for me, because this is the second book I've read with pacing issues I just can't get past, which is a huge bummer because my goodness I loved this world. It's super immersive, the characters are so three-dimensional, and there were moments that had me SOBBING. But again, the pacing was fantastic until it wasn't, and the story peaked too early.
Misaki was far and away the highlight for me. As a mom of boys, I related to SO much of her experience of loving her kids (kind of) while mourning who she had been before them. Like all moms, she had an entire life before them with her own identity and goals, and this book really did a beautiful job exploring how all of that can coexist alongside her love for the family she created. Her drive to raise her sons to be good men and not just what the world around them demanded really resonated. She was complicated and believable, and I loved watching her journey. I also loved her changing relationship to her husband as he slowly opened up to her despite cultural norms and expectations.
The battle and everything surrounding it were EPIC. The buildup was so well done, the stakes were very real, and the grief and loss tore through me. Any book that keeps me up late sobbing has to be incredibly well written. The author was willing to put the characters through a ton and then let us watch the aftermath for those left behind, and it was stunning. The familial relationships were so powerful, and the emotional impact of those moments was some of the best of the book in my opinion.
However. Once we got through the climax, there was still so much book left. The momentum and pacing up until that point was perfect, and then I suddenly wasn't sure where the story was going anymore. I liked seeing the aftermath and how the characters dealt with it together, but the story had already hit its emotional peak. New plot threads got introduced late in the book, which made the ending feel less focused and more confused.
That's really the only reason this isn't a five star book for me. The character development was fantastic. The relationships were all deep and meaningful. The emotional moments will stay with me for a very long time. Misaki's journey was handled with care and attention and spoke to me deeply. But all of that couldn't make up for the structure and pace of the story, which really needed to be tighter to make the ending live up to the first 75% of the story. It's a really excellent book, but it didn't stick the landing the way I'd hoped.

Read full review on ARC Library