Book: An Arcane Study of Stars by Sydney J. Shields
Reviewed by Ashley M
Rating: 4.5/5
Overview
Dates read: April 6 – April 28, 2026
If your personal aesthetic involves ink-stained fingers, flickering candlelight, and the kind of "sublime" intensity that makes your heart race, Sydney J. Shields has basically written a love letter to you. An Arcane Study of Stars is a high-stakes descent into an 18th-century-inspired, refreshingly queer-normative world where knowledge is a currency paid for in blood. After a soul-crushing rejection from Cygnus University, Claudia Jolicoeur bargains with a devilish stranger named Dorian to secure her spot, then has to survive the school while unraveling the mystery of Dorian's prison of stars.
What I Loved
Rotten beauty. Cygnus, with its leather-seated classrooms and a dining hall called "The Treaty," feels like a living character. Beneath the tea-and-crumpets energy, a cemetery for "fallen students" reminds you that failure here is permanent.
Rhetoric as a weapon. My favorite element: a metaphor isn't a stylistic choice, it's a tactical strike. Claudia is a powerhouse of intellectual desperation.
Rivals-to-lovers excellence. Claudia and Cassius MacLeod wage rhetorical war as debate partners. I felt personally targeted by Claudia charming a librarian to track which books Cassius checks out. Their chemistry moves from literal slaps to a terrifying-but-soft intimacy, and the butterflies were beyond real.
Haunting magic. The finite nature of celestial magic and the cost of reaching for divinity carried me from awe to terror right along with the characters.
What Didn't Work
The dialogue uses a very modern voice, contemporary swearing included, inside an 18th-century gothic frame. It occasionally pulled me out of the historical immersion, though it does make these messy, ambitious students feel like people you might know (and fear a little). Also, take the content warnings seriously: blood magic, spells carved into skin, and explicit romance.
Verdict
4.5/5 stars: Great! A gorgeous, high-velocity exploration of identity, agency, and the dangerous intersections of love and power, asking what you'd sacrifice to become "one of the greats." An absolute knockout for dark academia lovers.
Read next:
The Atlas Six by Olivie Blake
The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab
A Lesson in Vengeance by Victoria Lee
Full review on Medium: https://medium.com/p/f2fd7c10db1b
I received this book as an e-ARC from the author. All thoughts are my own.