The Love They Never Allowed Themselves to Want

Book: The Love Sleigh by Annabelle Anders

Reviewed by Maggie Hayes

Rating: 4.5/5

The Love Sleigh by Annabelle Anders
⭐⭐⭐⭐½ (4.5/5)
I really enjoyed Amanda and Simon's ex's best friend romance. We got a brief introduction to both characters in The Love Bus and The Love Ship (five-star reads—GO READ THEM NOW if you haven't!), but those glimpses didn't do either of them justice, especially Amanda.
Amanda broke my heart a little. She gave up medical school when she married Noah, putting all her eggs in their relationship basket, only to feel like an outsider after their divorce. Her family abandoned her because they didn't agree with her decisions, leaving her with only Noah's mother for comfort. And while it's wonderful that she and Noah parted amicably enough to remain friends, and that she's even gained a friend in his new wife, Amanda still feels like she's never had the chance to live life entirely on her own terms. That's A LOT for anyone to carry, especially when you add the guilt of falling for your ex-husband's best friend.
And Simon? SUCH a good man, carrying a world of guilt of his own. He's always been attracted to Amanda, but filed her firmly in the NEVER GONNA HAPPEN box when she started dating Noah. Now that they've been divorced for a few years, Simon is struggling to keep denying his feelings. He knows dating his best friend's ex is a major bro code violation, but he's never met anyone quite like Amanda. Meanwhile, he's a pediatric heart surgeon dealing with a patient whose parents are declining potentially life-saving surgery. This man cares SO MUCH, and I loved seeing a doctor who's compassionate and deeply invested in his patients rather than another arrogant, unfeeling hotshot.
I LOVE Amanda and Simon together. They complement each other so beautifully, believing in and supporting one another in ways they both desperately need. Their relationship feels so natural that it's impossible to imagine them NOT ending up together. There's simply no universe in which these two are going their separate ways once the snow melts and they leave Lovers' Lodge.
This book just solidifies Annabelle Anders as one of my favorite auto-buy authors. She's a MASTER at creating characters you care deeply about, and her ability to write a love story that's tender without being schmaltzy is unparalleled. I genuinely don't know how I'm supposed to survive until The Love Town releases.
Thank you to the author for providing an ARC!

Read full review on ARC Library