Sharp humor, seamless POVs, and little moments that made me melt. Five stars, no notes.

Book: You're A Mean One, Eva Finch: A Snowed In Christmas Novella by Willa Kay, Anna Jerr

Reviewed by Amanda

Rating: God Tier

Some books get a thoughtful closing annotation. This one got “fucking phenomenal. no notes.” And honestly? That still feels right.
The humor, the dialogue, the little emotional gut punches tucked between lines that made me laugh—I loved all of it. The chapters flowed so naturally from one POV into the next, picking up exactly where I wanted them to without ever feeling abrupt. It made this ridiculously easy to keep reading.
Everett’s little “There she is” whenever Eva smiles? I am embarrassingly susceptible to that specific thing, apparently. And Misha deserves his own round of applause. I loved him, and the supporting characters had some of my favorite lines in the entire book.
Underneath the humor were these observations about hope, love, and what we think we owe other people that really landed for me. My annotations went from laughing to highlighting something painfully sincere and right back again.
Five stars. Two chili peppers. Absolutely loved it.

Read full review on ARC Library