Blood Over Bright Haven

Book: Blood Over Bright Haven by M.L. Wang

Reviewed by plotdrunk

Rating: 4.5/5

I really liked this book, though it didn't quite stick the landing the way I hoped. The worldbuilding was fascinating and the magic system was so unique and clever, and I especially loved how the story used both to explore power and the cost of progress. The magic felt almost mathematical, which resonated with me a ton as an electrical engineer. And then once we realize what's really going on? The world took on a completely different color, and I love how the author was able to weave it into the story instead of hitting us over the head with it or telling us what we were supposed to think.
Sciona, our FMC, was far and away my favorite character. She's brilliant, ambitious, arrogant, and honestly shockingly selfish at times, but I thought she was incredibly well-written and believable. More than that though, I loved that she felt so different from the usual blade-wielding heroine or damsel in distress. As someone who is logical and technical and works in a male-dominated field, I related to a lot of her experiences throughout the story. She spent her entire life fighting to be taken seriously and truly believed that if she outsmarted all the men and worked hard enough then she'd earn her place. It was delicious (and frustrating!) to watch her worldview get completely ripped up as she learned what the system she worked so hard to join was really built on. She is definitely not always likeable, but she felt real and her transformation was profound.
I also loved a lot of her relationship to Thomil. Watching them go from awkwardly speaking to building genuine respect and care for each other despite their differences was so heartwarming, and I loved how much they challenged each other. Their partnership was built as they began to understand each other's pasts, but I thought their kiss at the end of the book really took away from the respect they had for each other. They really deserved either a developed romance throughout the book OR to stay platonic friends, and introducing a kiss at the very end felt like it cheapened the otherwise beautiful relationship.
The other thing that kept this from earning five stars was the ending. The buildup was incredible, the pacing was on point, the tension was there... and then we reached the climax of the story too early. There was still too much book left afterward. I think I understand what the author wanted to do, but the ending didn't have the impact that the climax did because I then couldn't tell if we were going to get another huge dramatic moment or not. It wasn't a bad ending, it just didn't land after the impeccable buildup.
Other than those things though, this was an excellent book. The characters were complicated and believable, the world is incredibly immersive, and the themes were thoughtful and woven in rather than served up on a platter for us. Sciona probably wasn't written to be widely relatable, and definitely not likeable, but she really, really resonated with me specifically. Her flaws made her interesting, and as I think many do, it feels really good to see parts of yourself in a character. I loved the story and the ideas underpinning it, and even with my frustrations about pacing and relationships I still thought it was great!

Read full review on ARC Library